Monday 17 November 2014

Begna Dugassa (PhD): In Defense of the Latest Amnesty International Report on the Repression in Oromia

I believe I am entitled to do this for four reasons.
The first reason is, I was born and raised in Oromia among the followers of the Oromo 
indigenous religion-- Waqefaata. I have witnessed human violations perpetuated by consecutive 
Ethiopian regimes. During the Haile Selassie regime, I witnessed my family members giving a 
quarter of their harvests to the Abyssinians and paying taxation without representation in the 
government. I witnessed many Oromo family members tried not to allow baptizing their children in 
the Abyssinian Orthodox Church. In the belief that if someone first goes through the Waqefaata 
ceremony known as Amachisa, the person will remain Waqefaata, my community members developed 
strategy to take their children through the indigenous ceremony first. Accordingly, in the Amachisa 
ceremony I got the name Tolera = things are good. After that, they had me baptized because the 
Oromo people were forced to baptize their children in the Orthodox Church. In the ceremony of 
baptism they gave me a name Gebre Giyorgis = the slave of George. I leave it to the readers to 
compare the differences in meaning between the two names. 
BECAUSE I AM OROMO!
I heard many stories about many innocent Oromo persons being charged with the crimes 
they did not commit. In most cases it was to free the Abyssinians from crimes they had committed. 
There is a case that I well knew- about an Oromo person being penalized for referring to the 
Supreme Court judge as (አንች=anchi) ‘you’, a term used in Amharic in reference to women,-instead 
of (እርስዎ=irswo) ‘you’ used in reference to the higher officials. The person did not use the term አንች 
(anchi) to undermine the Supreme Court. The reason was that he did not fully understand the 
Amharic language. This means that the Oromo people’s cultural rights are regularly violated and 
such violations are legal. As the UN document clearly states “human rights are indivisible, 
interrelated and interdependent”; the rights of the Oromo people to social, economic, political and 
cultural rights are being violated and this is clearly demonstrated in this case of a person being 
penalized for making a grammar mistake. 
Second, during the Dergi regime I witnessed many of my childhood friends involuntarily 
recruited into the Ethiopian militia. I have heard the mother of my childhood friend call herself “a 
mother goat” comparing herself to mother goats that have no right to defend their kits. Most 
militias died in the unnecessary wars and a few have returned physically incapacitated. Only a 
handful of them returned safely after spending their productive years in the war front. As I have 
elaborated in my previous works, many of these militias who returned back their village were 
infected with HIV/AIDS and they have contributed in a major way to the HIV/AIDS epidemic in 
Oromia. Third, my lived experience clearly taught me that under the Haile Selassie regime most of the 
Oromo people had to give a quarter to three quarters of their harvest to the Abyssinians. Under the 
Dergi regime, young Oromo men were involuntarily recruited to the militia. Oromo farmers were 
forced to subsidize the war by providing food at a fixed price. In my adulthood, I realized that the 
Oromo cultural, political, social and environmental rights had been violated. In understanding that a 
population’s health is determined by the social, economic, political, cultural and environmental 
conditions, I chose to make human rights and public health conditions in Oromia my research topic. 
I have been researching and writing on human rights and public health issues in Oromia for over a 
decade. My works are published in peer reviewed journals and a book. 
Fourth, since 1992 I have been a member of the Oromo Studies Association (OSA) and 
served in different capacities including as the president of the organization. Before and after I joined 
the OSA, members and invited guests have been investigating the socio-economic, political, cultural 
and environmental conditions in Oromia from different angles and academic fields. For me it is 
clear the major causes of the socio-economic problems that manifest as HIV/AIDS epidemic, 
famine, nutritional deficiency i.e. iodine deficiency and others primarily result from human rights 
violations. For my Ph.D thesis research and after, I have interviewed more than 55 Oromo 
nationals from different parts of Oromia, with different levels of education and work experiences. I 
have had the privilege to collect data in Oromo, Amharic and English languages and make sound 
intellectual and cultural judgments in interpreting them. This has given me a unique privilege in 
accessing the collective memory of the Oromo people and the ability to deeply understand the 
present realities. 
The Oromo people constitute the single largest national group in the Ethiopian Empire and 
in the Greater Horn of Africa. The size of the Oromo population and the geographical location of 
Oromia makes the Oromia regional state the heart of Ethiopia. Recognizing that Oromia is the 
richest and largest populous state, the TPLF-led Ethiopian government has been using collective 
violence to control and exploit Oromia, which is the key in controlling the Ethiopian political 
economy. The TPLF security forces are preoccupied with incapacitating the Oromo people by 
killing, imprisoning, torturing them and forcing others to flee their country. 
 I have carefully read the Report of AI, ‘BECAUSE I AM OROMO’ Sweeping Repression in 
the Oromia Region of Ethiopia2
 and read and listened to the response of the Ethiopiangovernment3
. If the Oromo people were empowered on their own affairs, they would have been 
able to give their own assessment and verdict on whether or not the report of AI reflects the 
objective reality in Oromia. Unfortunately, only human rights organizations such as AI, the Human 
Rights Watch, (HRW), Human Rights League of the Horn of Africa, (HRLHA), the Oromo Support 
Group (OSG) and scholarly organizations such as the Oromo Studies Association (OSA) can expose 
the social, political and economic crimes in Oromia at this historical moment. I affirm that the AI 
report clearly represents the objective realities in Oromia. Imprisonments, torture, arbitrary 
detentions, disappearances, rapes and killings are widespread human rights violations and they are 
day to day phenomena in Oromia Regional State. However, the report does not tell the whole story, 
as we shall see below. 
 First, the Tigray Peoples Liberation Front (TPLF) regime implements its political and 
economic objectives through a variety of strategies and tactics. It is highly militarized and 
repressive, and it tightly controls information and resources by manipulating foreign aids, domestic 
financial resources, and political appointments. This makes it difficult to know the exact number of 
Oromo political prisoners. The Ethiopian government uses formal prison cells as well as informal 
places to imprison and torture Oromo prisoners. There are registered and unregistered prison cells. 
For example military camps, police stations, government offices, private homes, hotels, health care 
centers and even schools are used to imprison Oromos. Many unregistered prisons are also found in 
remote and lowland areas and several of them are inaccessible to the public. In the estimate of 
HRLHA the number of Oromo political prisoners is about 30,000 (see HRLHA reports). 
Second, the TPLF led government does not allow Oromo independent political, social and 
human rights organizations to function. For example, the HRLHA is a human rights organization 
established to defend and promote human rights in the Horn of Africa. Initially it was formed in 
Ethiopia and registered as the Human Rights League (HRL). However, soon after the HRL was 
formed, Ethiopian security forces imprisoned the founders for several years and made others flee 
their country. Some of them- without committing a crime- have been jailed in the notorious 
Ethiopian prison cell known as Maikelawi for four years. The leaders did not commit any crimes. 
They were simply serving their community in different capacities i.e. church pastor, teacher, state 
and private media and human rights activism. 
 Third, Ethiopia is one of the ethnicized and racialized Empires. In Ethiopia, by virtue of 
birth and your ethnic background, you get a specific citizenship status. Until 1992, agape citizenship 
was assigned to the Amharic speakers with numerous privileges attached to it. Although the TPLF 
fiercely fought against such a discriminatory social stratification, when they took the power sadly 
they adopted the same principle and allocated to the Tigray nationals to enjoy the agape status. For 
example, the population of the Tigray nationals constitutes about five percent of the Ethiopian 
people; military generals took ninety- five percent of the positions. Disproportionately having more 
Tigray nationals in the military commanding positions tells us several important points. In the mind 
of the TPLF leadership, political power is determined not at the ballot box, but by the military. The 
TPLF government uses the Tigrayan-dominated army, police, security networks, and puppet 
organizations to destabilize independent institutions that are intended to facilitate changes in the 
social, economic, cultural, political and environmental conditions in Oromia and beyond. This was 
done to incapacitate, silence and control the Oromo people and deny them an independent 
leadership. This means the Ethiopian constitution, which is theoretically founded on the principle of 
federalism, is a sham designed to confuse the world community. 
Fourth, from the beginning, the TPLF forces functioned as organized criminals or bandits. 
To confuse the world community the TPLF- led Ethiopian government presents itself as if the 
EPRDF is a formal coalition of political organizations. In reality, it was the TPLF who used the 
prisoners of war (POWs) to form dozen of the so-called PDOs. Theoretically Oromo political 
prisoners formed the Oromo Peoples Democratic Organization (OPDO), the Amharas formed the 
Amhara Nation’s Democratic Movement ANDM and those from the south people formed the 
Southern Ethiopian Peoples’ Democratic movement, SEPDM and with the TPLF they formed the 
EPRDF in captivity. The political programs of these PDO organizations were assigned them by the 
TPLF. The formation of PDOs by the POWs in captivity makes the formation of EPRDF a fake. 
 By conservative estimates, the population of Ethiopia is about 100 million. The population 
of Tigray is about five million. The Oromos constitute about 45 million and the Amahara constitute 
about 23 million. The population of Southern Ethiopian People constitutes about 18 million. The 
other nine million are from the Ogden, Afar, Benshangual and Gambela regions. If the EPRDF is 
the coalition of several political parties, the decision- making power of these parties should have 
been distributed according to the number of the people they represent. If that is not the case, then 
serious human rights violations occurred when the TPLF formed the coalition of EPRDF4
 and 
made the decision making power of the TPLF equal to that of the OPDO, ANDM and SEPDM in 
the executive committee. 
Fifth, in the last twenty years the TPLF led government has engaged in systematic evictions 
of the Oromo people from their homes and farmlands in the name of leasing their lands to investors 
with no or little compensation. By evicting Oromo farmers from their homelands without or with 
little compensation, the TPLF regime has leased several millions hectares of Oromo lands to foreign 
investors such as the Chinese, Arabs, Indians, Malaysians, and European business people and local 
capitalists (Oakland Institute Reports5
). The investors are heavily using fertilizers, pesticides and 
herbicides and by that they polluted soil and rivers. This has resulted in the displacement of millions 
of Oromo farmers, simultaneously compromising their food security and exposing them to heavy 
toxic chemical pollutants. The water the Oromo people drink, the air they breathe and the foods 
they eat are now polluted. Besides that, chemical pollutants have severely harmed the biodiversity of 
the soil, the fertility of the land and the productivity of farm animals. 
 Sixth, in the name of expanding the city of Finfine (Addis Ababa) and selling Oromo land to 
investors, the Ethiopian government has evicted over three hundred thousand Oromos from their 
homes in the last ten years6
. Again the eviction was done with little or no compensation. The 
dispossession of land for lease to investors and the expansion of the city of Finfine have forced 
millions of Oromos to move to cities. Most of them have become homeless and street beggars. 
 Seventh, although the Ethiopian government claims that the cultural rights of people are 
respected, this is only partly true. The Oromo people are denied to use their own language as the 
language instruction in schools, courts and workplaces in their capital - Finfine. As of today, there 
are no public schools in Finfine that use Afaan Oromo as the language of instruction. No single 
court and health care service providers use Afaan Oromo in the Oromia capital. Millions of Oromos 
have to use Amharic to communicate with health care providers, judges, and prosecutors as well as 
police and in their daily lives. For this reasons they need the help of translators, because it is a 
foreign language for most of them. Indeed, one of the demands of the Oromo people is the right to 
make the Oromo language the official language in their own capital and the second federal official 
language. What are the impacts of violating such rights? (Ans. Two decades after the Ethiopian 
government recognized the existence of HIV/AIDS in the country; many Oromos who live in 
Finfinee and do not understand Amharic language, did not heard the existence of the virus (see, my 
work – Dugassa (2006) Ethiopian Language Policy and Health Promotion in Oromia). 
Eighth, the TPLF government policy is driven by a racist mindset and a divide and rule 
agenda. The TPLF racist mindset clearly manifests when you look at the ways it implements its own 
policies. For example, although they are a minority in their homeland, the Harari people who 
constitute about 185,000 are allowed to have their regional state7
. However, the population of Agaw 
that constitutes over 700,000 are denied to have their own regional state. There are three possible 
reasons that explain this discrepancy. The first reason is to make the Harari state viable one has to 
expand the territory and this requires incorporating the Oromo land and people. Doing this 
contributes to the fulfillment of the standing agenda of divide and incapacitates the Oromo people. 
The second reason is although the TPLF led government sees the Amhara- centric political 
organizations as a threat to its power; the Amahara and the Tigray people are culturally closer to 
each other than the Agaw people. Therefore, the TPLF chooses to violate the rights of the Agaw 
people rather than breaking apart the Amahara regional state. The third possible reason is that the 
TPLF is influenced by the longstanding racist view about the Agaw people and chooses to assign 
them the lower social status. 
 Ninth, the TPLF led government promotes inter and intra ethnic and religious conflicts and 
present itself as a peacemaker. Such conflicts are used to divide and weaken the Oromo people. 
Examples of such conflicts include the conflicts between Oromo and Gumuz in the West, Oromo 
and Ogden in the East and the South, between the Oromo-clan Borana and Guji and the Muslim 
Oromo and Christian Oromo. Conflict usually destabilizes the communities and results in property 
damage. This further aggravates the poverty level. 
 Tenth the TPLF rules with arms and has made fear the tool. In 2012, when the late prime 
minster unexpectedly died, they forced the whole society to mourn. They forced the whole society 
to go to public squares for the event. At these squares, thousands of heavily armed military stood for 
hours in silence or slow music and journalists stood to record videos of all the movements. People 
cried not necessarily for love of the PM but for the fear of the military, an uncertain future and 
worrying about the consequences of not crying. One of the many heartbreaking cases was 
organizing homeless men and women and taking them to the square. At one point the journalist 
asked the team leader who they were and why they were there. One of the team leaders said, “we are 
Eighth, the TPLF government policy is driven by a racist mindset and a divide and rule 
agenda. The TPLF racist mindset clearly manifests when you look at the ways it implements its own 
policies. For example, although they are a minority in their homeland, the Harari people who 
constitute about 185,000 are allowed to have their regional state7
. However, the population of Agaw 
that constitutes over 700,000 are denied to have their own regional state. There are three possible 
reasons that explain this discrepancy. The first reason is to make the Harari state viable one has to 
expand the territory and this requires incorporating the Oromo land and people. Doing this 
contributes to the fulfillment of the standing agenda of divide and incapacitates the Oromo people. 
The second reason is although the TPLF led government sees the Amhara- centric political 
organizations as a threat to its power; the Amahara and the Tigray people are culturally closer to 
each other than the Agaw people. Therefore, the TPLF chooses to violate the rights of the Agaw 
people rather than breaking apart the Amahara regional state. The third possible reason is that the 
TPLF is influenced by the longstanding racist view about the Agaw people and chooses to assign 
them the lower social status. 
 Ninth, the TPLF led government promotes inter and intra ethnic and religious conflicts and 
present itself as a peacemaker. Such conflicts are used to divide and weaken the Oromo people. 
Examples of such conflicts include the conflicts between Oromo and Gumuz in the West, Oromo 
and Ogden in the East and the South, between the Oromo-clan Borana and Guji and the Muslim 
Oromo and Christian Oromo. Conflict usually destabilizes the communities and results in property 
damage. This further aggravates the poverty level. 
 Tenth the TPLF rules with arms and has made fear the tool. In 2012, when the late prime 
minster unexpectedly died, they forced the whole society to mourn. They forced the whole society 
to go to public squares for the event. At these squares, thousands of heavily armed military stood for 
hours in silence or slow music and journalists stood to record videos of all the movements. People 
cried not necessarily for love of the PM but for the fear of the military, an uncertain future and 
worrying about the consequences of not crying. One of the many heartbreaking cases was 
organizing homeless men and women and taking them to the square. At one point the journalist 
asked the team leader who they were and why they were there. One of the team leaders said, “we are 
Eighth, the TPLF government policy is driven by a racist mindset and a divide and rule 
agenda. The TPLF racist mindset clearly manifests when you look at the ways it implements its own 
policies. For example, although they are a minority in their homeland, the Harari people who 
constitute about 185,000 are allowed to have their regional state7
. However, the population of Agaw 
that constitutes over 700,000 are denied to have their own regional state. There are three possible 
reasons that explain this discrepancy. The first reason is to make the Harari state viable one has to 
expand the territory and this requires incorporating the Oromo land and people. Doing this 
contributes to the fulfillment of the standing agenda of divide and incapacitates the Oromo people. 
The second reason is although the TPLF led government sees the Amhara- centric political 
organizations as a threat to its power; the Amahara and the Tigray people are culturally closer to 
each other than the Agaw people. Therefore, the TPLF chooses to violate the rights of the Agaw 
people rather than breaking apart the Amahara regional state. The third possible reason is that the 
TPLF is influenced by the longstanding racist view about the Agaw people and chooses to assign 
them the lower social status. 
 Ninth, the TPLF led government promotes inter and intra ethnic and religious conflicts and 
present itself as a peacemaker. Such conflicts are used to divide and weaken the Oromo people. 
Examples of such conflicts include the conflicts between Oromo and Gumuz in the West, Oromo 
and Ogden in the East and the South, between the Oromo-clan Borana and Guji and the Muslim 
Oromo and Christian Oromo. Conflict usually destabilizes the communities and results in property 
damage. This further aggravates the poverty level. 
 Tenth the TPLF rules with arms and has made fear the tool. In 2012, when the late prime 
minster unexpectedly died, they forced the whole society to mourn. They forced the whole society 
to go to public squares for the event. At these squares, thousands of heavily armed military stood for 
hours in silence or slow music and journalists stood to record videos of all the movements. People 
cried not necessarily for love of the PM but for the fear of the military, an uncertain future and 
worrying about the consequences of not crying. One of the many heartbreaking cases was 
organizing homeless men and women and taking them to the square. 

No comments:

Post a Comment